Skip to content
Live demo
A 3D map of Shelter Island’s census tracts, with each tract raised and lightened by its median household income.

Shelter Island, New York · population, demographics and census data

Home to 2,125 people, the 607th largest of New York’s 1,289 places.

Population
2,125 ±647. Rank 607 of 1,289 in New York
Median household income
$165,734 ±$120,200. New York $85,974 · US $80,734
Median age
41.3 ±2.3. New York 39.8 · US 38.9

ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates, U.S. Census Bureau

About Shelter Island

Shelter Island’s median age is 41.3 (±2.3), according to the ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates.

With 2,125 residents, treat these as rough estimates. The survey reaches only a sample of households, so a small place’s figures can swing widely from year to year, and small differences may not mean much.

± is each figure’s margin of error, at 90% confidence, and † marks one too uncertain to lean on. Under each percentage in the tables is the number it counts. How the margins are worked out.

FIPS code 3666828

Highlights

What stands out in Shelter Island

The numbers where Shelter Island sits furthest from New York and the nation, or past a recognized policy benchmark.

Past a policy benchmark

  • 100.0%

    Very high

    Renters paying 30% or more of income

    That’s higher than both New York (49.2%) and the US (47.6%). HUD counts households paying 30% or more of income on housing as cost-burdened. It’s the highest of 842 New York places.

Furthest from the national picture

  • 20.0%

    5.5× the US

    Take public transit

    That’s about the same as New York (22.4%) but higher than the US (3.5%). It’s the 39th highest of 856 New York places.

  • $1,025,400

    3× the US

    Median home value

    That’s higher than both New York ($423,800) and the US ($332,700). It’s the 64th highest of 837 New York places.

  • 10.7%

    Very low

    Households that rent

    That’s lower than both New York (45.7%) and the US (34.8%).

  • 0.0%

    Very low

    Asian, not Hispanic

    That’s lower than both New York (9.0%) and the US (5.9%). It’s the 114th lowest of 857 New York places.

  • 56.0%

    1.5× the US

    Bachelor’s degree or more

    That’s not statistically different from New York (40.2%) but higher than the US (35.7%).

2010–2014 to 2020–2024

How Shelter Island changed in ten years

The community added 855 people. It got younger and more foreign-born, and poverty rose 0.9 points.

Population, change since 2010–14

+67.3% in the community, +1.3% in New York and +6.6% in the US.

Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A00001.

Show data
Population, change since 2010–14, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A00001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010–140.0%0.0%0.0%
2011–15+3.4%+0.4%+0.8%
2012–16+14.4%+0.5%+1.4%
2013–17+8.0%+1.0%+2.2%
2014–18+33.5%+0.1%+2.8%
2015–19+62.4%−0.1%+3.4%
2016–20+55.9%−0.4%+4.0%
2017–21+96.8%+2.7%+5.0%
2018–22+101.9%+2.0%+5.4%
2019–23+79.6%+1.4%+5.8%
2020–24+67.3%+1.3%+6.6%
Embed

Median household income, in 2024 dollars

+62.3% in the community, +10.3% in New York and +13.7% in the US.

Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A14006.

Show data
Median household income, in 2024 dollars, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A14006.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010–14$102,120$77,929$71,018
2011–15$99,227$78,567$71,435
2012–16$100,728$79,493$72,401
2013–17$141,118$80,412$73,862
2014–18$102,435$81,698$75,407
2015–19$98,081$84,130$77,198
2016–20$118,230$86,284$78,856
2017–21$151,684$87,118$80,006
2018–22$106,007$87,233$80,548
2019–23$133,212$87,063$80,845
2020–24$165,734$85,974$80,734
Embed

Living in poverty

+0.9 points in the community, −1.6 points in New York and −3.1 points in the US.

Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A13004.

Show data
Living in poverty, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A13004.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010–140.0%15.6%15.6%
2011–152.3%15.7%15.5%
2012–162.2%15.5%15.1%
2013–174.3%15.1%14.6%
2014–184.5%14.6%14.1%
2015–195.0%14.1%13.4%
2016–208.8%13.6%12.8%
2017–218.9%13.5%12.6%
2018–220.3%13.6%12.5%
2019–231.2%13.7%12.4%
2020–240.9%14.0%12.5%
Embed

Bachelor’s degree or more

−0.4 points in the community, +6.5 points in New York and +6.4 points in the US.

Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A12001.

Show data
Bachelor’s degree or more, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A12001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010–1456.4%33.7%29.3%
2011–1549.0%34.2%29.8%
2012–1651.4%34.7%30.3%
2013–1754.1%35.3%30.9%
2014–1855.3%35.9%31.5%
2015–1947.7%36.6%32.1%
2016–2061.4%37.5%32.9%
2017–2164.1%38.1%33.7%
2018–2264.2%38.8%34.3%
2019–2355.0%39.6%35.0%
2020–2456.0%40.2%35.7%
Embed

Median home value, in 2024 dollars

+14.0% in the community, +12.5% in New York and +42.6% in the US.

Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A10036.

Show data
Median home value, in 2024 dollars, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, 2010–14 to 2020–24, table A10036.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010–14$899,239$376,719$233,308
2011–15$875,025$375,674$236,751
2012–16$869,772$374,685$241,720
2013–17$884,771$375,381$247,905
2014–18$902,113$377,954$256,264
2015–19$956,202$385,355$267,181
2016–20$1,040,140$394,314$278,810
2017–21$1,011,936$394,806$283,875
2018–22$1,007,853$411,695$302,152
2019–23$1,048,937$414,840$312,314
2020–24$1,025,400$423,800$332,700
Embed

ACS 5-year estimates. Each point is the five years ending then, and neighboring points share years. Dollar values are in 2024 dollars. The Census Bureau redraws census-designated places for each census, last for 2020, so part of a change can be a new boundary rather than new people.

Shelter Island in 2010–2014 and 2020–2024
Indicator2010–20142020–2024ChangeNew York’s change
Population1,2702,125+67.3%+1.3%
Median age51.441.3−10.1 years+1.7 years
65 and over20.4%18.7%−1.7 points+3.8 points
Born outside the US11.6%16.6%+5.0 points+0.5 points
Hispanic or Latino13.9%31.8%+17.9 points+1.7 points
Median household income$102,120$165,734+62.3%+10.3%
Living in poverty0.0%0.9%+0.9 points−1.6 points
Bachelor’s degree or more56.4%56.0%−0.4 points+6.5 points
Households that rent15.5%10.7%−4.8 points−0.5 points
Median gross rent$1,765n/an/a+9.3%
Median home value$899,239$1,025,400+14.0%+12.5%

1 census tract

Shelter Island on the map

Shelter Island is smaller than a census tract, the smallest area these figures reach, so the map shows the tract it sits in, with the land around it.

A map of Shelter Island’s 1 census tracts, shaded by median household income, lighter where incomes are higher.
Median household income, by census tract, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates. Boundaries, roads and water: Social Explorer.

People

Who lives in Shelter Island

Its median age of 41.3 is about the same as New York (39.8) but higher than the US (38.9).

Age

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A01001.

Show data
Age, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A01001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Under 18
27.3% ±12.7%
, number 580 ±323
20.5% ±<0.1%
, number 4,065,312 ±9,342
22.0% ±<0.1%
, number 73,517,834 ±38,890
18 to 24
8.0% ±8.6%
, number 169 ±190
8.9% ±<0.1%
, number 1,769,870 ±7,606
9.1% ±<0.1%
, number 30,597,362 ±37,780
25 to 34
0.0% ±1.3%
, number 0 ±28
14.2% ±<0.1%
, number 2,815,828 ±1,407
13.7% ±<0.1%
, number 45,806,540 ±10,200
35 to 44
30.4% ±10.5%
, number 646 ±298
13.0% ±<0.1%
, number 2,572,190 ±9,803
13.2% ±<0.1%
, number 44,237,292 ±43,510
45 to 54
9.1% ±6.7%
, number 194 ±153
12.2% ±<0.1%
, number 2,431,164 ±1,172
12.2% ±<0.1%
, number 40,743,799 ±8,564
55 to 64
6.5% ±7.2%
, number 139 ±158
13.3% ±0.1%
, number 2,643,974 ±10,830
12.7% ±<0.1%
, number 42,386,044 ±41,500
65 to 74
14.9% ±8.0%
, number 316 ±196
10.3% ±<0.1%
, number 2,053,493 ±9,582
10.2% ±<0.1%
, number 34,092,907 ±38,800
75 and over
3.8% ±3.5%
, number 81 ±79
7.6% ±<0.1%
, number 1,500,535 ±8,324
7.0% ±<0.1%
, number 23,540,721 ±31,560
Embed

Race and ethnicity

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A04001.

Show data
Race and ethnicity, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A04001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
White, not Hispanic
57.0% ±16.2%
, number 1,212 ±505
52.8% ±<0.1%
, number 10,473,790 ±6,104
57.4% ±<0.1%
, number 192,214,378 ±30,950
Hispanic or Latino
31.8% ±28.3%
, number 675 ±635
19.8%
, number 3,936,085
19.3% ±<0.1%
, number 64,759,370 ±1,547
Black, not Hispanic
0.0% ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
13.4% ±<0.1%
, number 2,661,771 ±7,857
11.9% ±<0.1%
, number 39,896,127 ±46,710
Asian, not Hispanic
0.0% ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
9.0% ±<0.1%
, number 1,782,460 ±5,315
5.9% ±<0.1%
, number 19,678,814 ±22,770
Other or multiracial
11.2% ±17.3%
, number 238 ±375
5.0% ±0.1%
, number 998,260 ±12,660
5.5% ±<0.1%
, number 18,373,810 ±69,180
Embed

Language spoken at home

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table C16001.

Show data
Language spoken at home, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table C16001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
English only
73.7% ±16.4%
, number 1,369 ±480
69.1% ±0.1%
, number 12,975,172 ±23,810
77.7% ±0.1%
, number 245,767,039 ±221,000
Spanish
26.3% ±22.5%
, number 489 ±438
14.8% ±0.1%
, number 2,772,893 ±13,480
13.6% ±<0.1%
, number 42,869,908 ±143,800
Other Indo-European
0.0% ±1.5%
, number 0 ±28
9.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,694,224 ±17,370
3.9% ±<0.1%
, number 12,249,474 ±54,760
Asian and Pacific Island
0.0% ±1.7%
, number 0 ±31
5.2% ±0.1%
, number 966,819 ±10,980
3.6% ±<0.1%
, number 11,320,253 ±40,030
Arabic and other
0.0% ±1.1%
, number 0 ±20
1.9% ±<0.1%
, number 363,304 ±8,699
1.2% ±<0.1%
, number 3,935,874 ±33,550
Embed

Marital status

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A11001.

Show data
Marital status, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A11001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Now married
53.6% ±22.1%
, number 862 ±246
44.4% ±0.1%
, number 7,325,956 ±22,710
47.8% ±0.1%
, number 131,199,078 ±272,700
Never married
31.9% ±18.9%
, number 514 ±341
38.9% ±0.1%
, number 6,416,945 ±19,340
34.4% ±0.1%
, number 94,480,845 ±211,900
Divorced
8.9% ±8.1%
, number 143 ±137
9.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,480,795 ±9,773
10.6% ±<0.1%
, number 29,074,059 ±73,390
Widowed
5.6% ±6.8%
, number 90 ±113
5.6% ±<0.1%
, number 916,462 ±6,995
5.6% ±<0.1%
, number 15,250,943 ±26,710
Separated
0.0% ±1.2%
, number 0 ±20
2.2% ±<0.1%
, number 355,507 ±4,914
1.7% ±<0.1%
, number 4,592,038 ±29,170
Embed

Where people lived a year ago

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A08001.

Show data
Where people lived a year ago, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A08001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Same home
96.8% ±9.6%
, number 2,057 ±659
90.1% ±0.1%
, number 17,705,028 ±18,170
87.7% ±0.1%
, number 290,692,803 ±173,800
Same county
0.0% ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
5.1% ±0.1%
, number 997,046 ±14,260
6.3% ±<0.1%
, number 20,792,831 ±117,600
Another county in the state
0.0% ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
2.6% ±<0.1%
, number 513,945 ±8,119
3.1% ±<0.1%
, number 10,316,864 ±51,200
Another state
3.2% ±4.9%
, number 68 ±107
1.5% ±<0.1%
, number 289,410 ±5,564
2.3% ±<0.1%
, number 7,577,400 ±40,570
Another country
0.0% ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
0.7% ±<0.1%
, number 138,671 ±4,751
0.6% ±<0.1%
, number 2,060,087 ±23,560
Embed

Top countries of birth, among those born abroad

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A07001.

Show data
Top countries of birth, among those born abroad, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A07001.
Shelter Island
Mexico57.7%
, number 203
Ecuador23.0%
, number 81
El Salvador19.3%
, number 68
Embed
All the numbers
People: Shelter Island compared with New York and the United States
IndicatorShelter IslandNew YorkUSRank in New York*Table
Population
2,125 ±647
19,852,366
334,922,499
607thA00001
People per square mile
324 ±99
421
95
827thA00002
Land area (square miles)
7
–
–
–A00002
Median age
41.3 ±2.3
39.8 ±0.1
38.9 ±0.1
471stA01004
Under 18
27.3% ±12.7%
, number 580 ±323
20.5% ±<0.1%
, number 4,065,312 ±9,342
22.0% ±<0.1%
, number 73,517,834 ±38,890
78thB02002
65 and over
18.7% ±8.1%
, number 397 ±211
17.9% ±0.1%
, number 3,554,028 ±12,690
17.2% ±<0.1%
, number 57,633,628 ±50,010
464thB02002
Born outside the US
16.6%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±15.4%
, number 352 ±344
22.8% ±0.1%
, number 4,526,014 ±18,560
14.1% ±<0.1%
, number 47,349,078 ±143,600
205thA06001
Speak a language other than English at home
26.3% ±16.4%
, number 489 ±441
30.9% ±0.1%
, number 5,797,240 ±26,070
22.3% ±0.1%
, number 70,375,509 ±162,500
175thC16001
Veterans (adults)
0.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±0.9%
, number 0 ±14
3.7% ±<0.1%
, number 581,776 ±5,645
6.2% ±<0.1%
, number 16,185,883 ±45,250
845thA16002
Living with a disability
3.8%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±3.6%
, number 80 ±81
12.6% ±0.1%
, number 2,482,006 ±11,910
13.3% ±<0.1%
, number 43,869,797 ±68,920
841stB18101
Women 15–50 who had a baby in the past year
0.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±2.6%
, number 0 ±14
4.9% ±0.1%
, number 228,276 ±4,383
5.1% ±<0.1%
, number 4,009,203 ±20,900
751stB13002
Lived in the same home a year ago
96.8% ±9.6%
, number 2,057 ±659
90.1% ±0.1%
, number 17,705,028 ±18,170
87.7% ±0.1%
, number 290,692,803 ±173,800
60thA08001
White, not Hispanic
57.0% ±16.2%
, number 1,212 ±505
52.8% ±<0.1%
, number 10,473,790 ±6,104
57.4% ±<0.1%
, number 192,214,378 ±30,950
719thA04001
Hispanic or Latino
31.8%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±28.3%
, number 675 ±635
19.8%
, number 3,936,085
19.3% ±<0.1%
, number 64,759,370 ±1,547
56thA04001
Black, not Hispanic
0.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
13.4% ±<0.1%
, number 2,661,771 ±7,857
11.9% ±<0.1%
, number 39,896,127 ±46,710
777thA04001
Asian, not Hispanic
0.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±0.7%
, number 0 ±14
9.0% ±<0.1%
, number 1,782,460 ±5,315
5.9% ±<0.1%
, number 19,678,814 ±22,770
744thA04001

*1 is the highest. Population is ranked among all places, and the rest among those of 1,000 people or more, whose figures can be ranked. Ranks use 5-year estimates, the only ones covering every community, so they can differ slightly from the figures here.

Income and work

Income and work

Household income

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A14001.

Show data
Household income, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A14001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Under $25,000
2.9% ±4.7%
, number 20 ±33
16.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,236,847 ±10,050
14.6% ±<0.1%
, number 18,908,588 ±41,540
$25,000 to $49,999
10.7% ±15.4%
, number 73 ±107
15.1% ±0.1%
, number 1,162,784 ±10,270
16.7% ±<0.1%
, number 21,624,902 ±39,130
$50,000 to $74,999
6.9% ±11.2%
, number 47 ±77
13.6% ±0.1%
, number 1,051,347 ±9,362
15.5% ±<0.1%
, number 20,031,683 ±36,850
$75,000 to $99,999
0.0% ±2.1%
, number 0 ±14
11.4% ±0.1%
, number 883,133 ±7,713
12.6% ±<0.1%
, number 16,319,799 ±42,700
$100,000 to $149,999
27.5% ±22.1%
, number 188 ±158
16.7% ±0.1%
, number 1,287,671 ±9,891
17.5% ±<0.1%
, number 22,670,921 ±58,280
$150,000 to $199,999
6.7% ±10.6%
, number 46 ±73
10.1% ±0.1%
, number 782,846 ±6,957
9.6% ±<0.1%
, number 12,405,370 ±57,560
$200,000 or more
45.2% ±18.9%
, number 309 ±149
17.1% ±0.1%
, number 1,318,018 ±9,233
13.4% ±0.1%
, number 17,266,233 ±82,370
Embed

What residents do for work

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A17004.

Show data
What residents do for work, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A17004.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Transportation and warehousing
29.9% ±34.7%
, number 319 ±387
5.7% ±0.1%
, number 539,944 ±6,614
5.9% ±<0.1%
, number 9,568,767 ±29,300
Professional and business services
23.9% ±14.7%
, number 255 ±181
13.3% ±0.1%
, number 1,264,134 ±11,530
12.6% ±<0.1%
, number 20,282,450 ±59,650
Construction
11.2% ±10.0%
, number 119 ±115
5.7% ±0.1%
, number 540,499 ±7,369
6.9% ±<0.1%
, number 11,167,040 ±57,000
Public administration
9.1% ±12.2%
, number 97 ±135
4.8% ±0.1%
, number 453,346 ±6,404
4.7% ±<0.1%
, number 7,624,243 ±43,950
Education and health care
8.3% ±8.4%
, number 89 ±95
29.3% ±0.1%
, number 2,795,096 ±14,940
23.5% ±0.1%
, number 37,913,663 ±133,200
Finance, insurance and real estate
8.0% ±10.9%
, number 85 ±120
8.0% ±0.1%
, number 760,434 ±9,193
6.7% ±<0.1%
, number 10,783,159 ±41,000
Manufacturing
6.4% ±9.8%
, number 68 ±107
5.7% ±0.1%
, number 547,502 ±5,537
9.9% ±<0.1%
, number 15,940,000 ±38,890
Wholesale trade
3.3% ±5.4%
, number 35 ±59
1.8% ±<0.1%
, number 175,311 ±4,134
2.2% ±<0.1%
, number 3,507,744 ±16,260
Embed

Where workers come from and go

Shelter Island has 548 jobs and 559 employed residents. 444 people commute in to work and 455 commute out, while 104 both live and work here. The most commuters come from Shelter Island Heights CDP.

Jobs in the community548
Employed residents559

Most commuters come from

  • Shelter Island Heights CDP: 92
  • Southold CDP: 40
  • Greenport village: 28

Most residents commute to

  • New York city: 126
  • Shelter Island Heights CDP: 63
  • Greenport village: 10
Source: LEHD LODES 2023.
Show data
Who works here, and who commutes, Shelter Island. Source: LEHD LODES 2023.
Shelter Island
Live and work here104
Work here, live elsewhere444
Live here, work elsewhere455
Embed
All the numbers
Income and work: Shelter Island compared with New York and the United States
IndicatorShelter IslandNew YorkUSRank in New York*Table
Median household income
$165,734† (too uncertain to lean on) ±$120,200
$85,974 ±$402
$80,734 ±$166
112thA14006
Income per person
$58,080 ±$19,570
$50,712 ±$237
$44,673 ±$122
276thA14024
Income inequality (Gini index)
0.309 ±0.081
0.517 ±0.002
0.483
834thA14028
Living in poverty
0.9%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±1.0%
, number 20 ±22
14.0% ±0.2%
, number 2,711,742 ±29,110
12.5% ±0.1%
, number 40,735,661 ±275,900
832ndA13004
Unemployment rate
5.3%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±7.2%
, number 60 ±84
6.4% ±0.1%
, number 648,175 ±6,671
5.2% ±<0.1%
, number 8,902,365 ±38,980
353rdA17005
No health insurance
8.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±9.0%
, number 170 ±198
5.1% ±0.1%
, number 993,274 ±11,380
8.4% ±<0.1%
, number 27,734,911 ±158,900
70thA20001

*1 is the highest. Population is ranked among all places, and the rest among those of 1,000 people or more, whose figures can be ranked. Ranks use 5-year estimates, the only ones covering every community, so they can differ slightly from the figures here.

Education

More college degrees than the US

56.0% of adults 25 and over have a bachelor’s degree or more, not statistically different from New York (40.2%) but higher than the US (35.7%).

Highest level of education

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A12001.

Show data
Highest level of education, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A12001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Less than high school
14.6% ±12.1%
, number 201 ±177
12.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,684,470 ±13,050
10.4% ±<0.1%
, number 23,992,410 ±82,490
High school only
17.8% ±13.3%
, number 245 ±197
24.3% ±0.2%
, number 3,404,326 ±21,130
26.0% ±0.1%
, number 60,094,716 ±262,500
Some college
11.6% ±9.9%
, number 160 ±144
23.5% ±0.1%
, number 3,289,757 ±14,940
27.9% ±0.1%
, number 64,356,961 ±143,900
Bachelor’s degree
30.2% ±17.0%
, number 415 ±264
22.4% ±0.1%
, number 3,133,832 ±16,370
21.6% ±0.1%
, number 49,868,171 ±191,400
Graduate degree
25.8% ±14.3%
, number 355 ±223
17.9% ±0.1%
, number 2,504,799 ±16,580
14.1% ±0.1%
, number 32,495,045 ±159,600
Embed
All the numbers
Education: Shelter Island compared with New York and the United States
IndicatorShelter IslandNew YorkUSRank in New York*Table
Bachelor’s degree or more
56.0% ±18.9%
, number 770 ±346
40.2% ±0.2%
, number 5,638,631 ±23,300
35.7% ±0.1%
, number 82,363,216 ±249,200
208thA12001
High school graduate or more
85.4% ±17.4%
, number 1,175 ±423
88.0% ±0.2%
, number 12,332,714 ±34,820
89.6% ±0.2%
, number 206,814,893 ±389,500
775thA12001

*1 is the highest. Population is ranked among all places, and the rest among those of 1,000 people or more, whose figures can be ranked. Ranks use 5-year estimates, the only ones covering every community, so they can differ slightly from the figures here.

Housing

Incomes outran home values

The median home is worth $1,025,400. After inflation, home values rose 14% from 2010–2014 to 2020–2024, while household income rose 62%.

Housing costs and income, 2010–2014 to 2020–2024, after inflation

Source: ACS 5-year, table A10036, A18009, A14006.

Show data
Housing costs and income, 2010–2014 to 2020–2024, after inflation, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 5-year, table A10036, A18009, A14006.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Median home value+14.0%+12.5%+42.6%
Median household income+62.3%+10.3%+13.7%
Embed

Types of homes

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10032.

Show data
Types of homes, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10032.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Single-family, detached
94.1% ±7.9%
, number 1,327 ±217
41.2% ±0.1%
, number 3,533,093 ±10,010
61.3% ±0.1%
, number 88,075,458 ±149,800
Single-family, attached
5.2% ±7.3%
, number 73 ±103
5.5% ±0.1%
, number 470,247 ±6,314
6.2% ±<0.1%
, number 8,955,086 ±33,580
2 to 4 units
0.7% ±1.5%
, number 10 ±21
16.5% ±0.1%
, number 1,416,392 ±10,690
7.7% ±<0.1%
, number 11,031,346 ±42,810
5 to 19 units
0.0% ±1.4%
, number 0 ±20
9.6% ±0.1%
, number 822,921 ±8,722
8.8% ±<0.1%
, number 12,625,154 ±51,990
20 or more units
0.0% ±1.4%
, number 0 ±20
25.1% ±0.1%
, number 2,156,358 ±11,210
10.3% ±<0.1%
, number 14,859,547 ±31,000
Mobile homes and other
0.0% ±1.4%
, number 0 ±20
2.2% ±<0.1%
, number 186,230 ±3,175
5.7% ±<0.1%
, number 8,228,764 ±48,580
Embed

When homes were built

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10055.

Show data
When homes were built, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10055.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
2010 or later
0.0% ±4.1%
, number 0 ±28
6.0% ±0.1%
, number 465,552 ±5,637
11.6% ±<0.1%
, number 14,996,534 ±51,640
2000 to 2009
0.0% ±2.9%
, number 0 ±20
6.4% ±0.1%
, number 492,327 ±6,770
13.8% ±<0.1%
, number 17,865,859 ±70,250
1980 to 1999
22.5% ±18.5%
, number 154 ±132
13.5% ±0.1%
, number 1,044,265 ±8,623
25.3% ±<0.1%
, number 32,758,140 ±75,080
1960 to 1979
42.2% ±26.5%
, number 288 ±194
22.2% ±0.1%
, number 1,716,137 ±11,310
23.9% ±<0.1%
, number 30,938,809 ±78,560
Before 1960
35.3% ±21.4%
, number 241 ±157
51.9% ±0.2%
, number 4,004,365 ±18,210
25.3% ±<0.1%
, number 32,668,154 ±83,060
Embed
All the numbers
Housing: Shelter Island compared with New York and the United States
IndicatorShelter IslandNew YorkUSRank in New York*Table
Housing units
1,410 ±198
–
–
–A10001
Households
683 ±165
–
–
–A10008
People per household
3.11 ±0.74
2.49 ±0.01
2.53 ±0.01
101stA10003
Households that rent
10.7%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±14.9%
, number 73 ±103
45.7% ±0.1%
, number 3,525,661 ±12,360
34.8% ±0.1%
, number 45,017,354 ±163,600
694thA10060
Vacant homes
51.6% ±8.2%
, number 727 ±154
10.0% ±0.1%
, number 862,595 ±12,630
10.1% ±0.1%
, number 14,547,859 ±200,400
10thA10047, A10060
Median gross rent
n/a
$1,621 ±$7
$1,413 ±$2
–A18009
Median home value
$1,025,400 ±$184,400
$423,800 ±$1,627
$332,700 ±$236
64thA10036
Renters paying 30% or more of income
100.0% ±33.2%
, number 73 ±106
49.2% ±0.4%
, number 1,733,205 ±13,820
47.6% ±0.2%
, number 21,422,415 ±63,960
1stA18002
Owners paying 30% or more of income
3.3%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±7.0%
, number 20 ±43
27.4% ±0.2%
, number 1,149,847 ±8,996
22.5% ±0.1%
, number 18,961,895 ±39,930
839thA10040
Homes built before 1960
35.3% ±21.4%
, number 241 ±157
51.9% ±0.2%
, number 4,004,365 ±18,210
25.3% ±<0.1%
, number 32,668,154 ±83,060
621stA10055

*1 is the highest. Population is ranked among all places, and the rest among those of 1,000 people or more, whose figures can be ranked. Ranks use 5-year estimates, the only ones covering every community, so they can differ slightly from the figures here.

Getting around

How people get around

43.2% of those who travel to work spend 30 minutes or more getting there.

How people get to work

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A09005.

Show data
How people get to work, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A09005.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Drive alone
48.1% ±37.4%
, number 513 ±439
48.8% ±0.1%
, number 4,538,595 ±14,030
68.8% ±0.1%
, number 109,447,738 ±95,800
Carpool
6.8% ±9.3%
, number 73 ±103
6.3% ±0.1%
, number 589,956 ±7,930
8.5% ±<0.1%
, number 13,569,614 ±52,500
Public transit
20.0% ±15.3%
, number 213 ±181
22.4% ±0.1%
, number 2,080,498 ±12,130
3.5% ±<0.1%
, number 5,573,279 ±22,170
Walk
0.0% ±1.3%
, number 0 ±14
5.6% ±0.1%
, number 520,678 ±7,409
2.4% ±<0.1%
, number 3,772,609 ±17,080
Work from home
25.1% ±16.7%
, number 268 ±202
14.9% ±0.1%
, number 1,389,935 ±12,520
15.1% ±<0.1%
, number 24,042,489 ±82,860
Other
0.0% ±2.3%
, number 0 ±24
2.0% ±<0.1%
, number 186,905 ±4,373
1.7% ±<0.1%
, number 2,708,365 ±17,940
Embed

Time spent getting to work

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table B09001.

Show data
Time spent getting to work, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table B09001.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
Under 10 minutes
44.7% ±41.4%
, number 357 ±388
10.2% ±0.1%
, number 806,870 ±8,248
12.7% ±<0.1%
, number 17,153,542 ±40,730
10 to 19 minutes
0.0% ±2.5%
, number 0 ±20
22.3% ±0.2%
, number 1,767,485 ±13,040
28.7% ±<0.1%
, number 38,741,521 ±54,980
20 to 29 minutes
12.1% ±15.5%
, number 97 ±136
18.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,426,452 ±11,340
21.3% ±<0.1%
, number 28,723,420 ±52,330
30 to 39 minutes
21.9% ±13.5%
, number 175 ±146
17.0% ±0.1%
, number 1,347,213 ±10,630
16.9% ±<0.1%
, number 22,853,044 ±46,230
40 to 59 minutes
0.0% ±2.5%
, number 0 ±20
15.7% ±0.1%
, number 1,239,933 ±10,680
11.9% ±<0.1%
, number 16,024,037 ±44,090
60 minutes or more
21.3% ±15.2%
, number 170 ±155
16.8% ±0.1%
, number 1,328,679 ±10,080
8.6% ±<0.1%
, number 11,576,041 ±36,550
Embed

Vehicles per household

Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10030.

Show data
Vehicles per household, Shelter Island. Source: ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table A10030.
Shelter IslandNew YorkUnited States
None
0.0% ±2.9%
, number 0 ±20
29.2% ±0.1%
, number 2,256,981 ±12,070
8.4% ±<0.1%
, number 10,793,323 ±36,450
One
27.4% ±22.7%
, number 187 ±161
33.6% ±0.2%
, number 2,592,316 ±12,610
33.1% ±0.1%
, number 42,801,892 ±122,600
Two
35.1% ±22.1%
, number 240 ±162
25.4% ±0.2%
, number 1,964,621 ±12,690
36.6% ±0.1%
, number 47,334,152 ±191,100
Three or more
37.5% ±18.9%
, number 256 ±144
11.8% ±0.1%
, number 908,728 ±7,195
21.9% ±0.1%
, number 28,298,129 ±85,940
Embed
All the numbers
Getting around: Shelter Island compared with New York and the United States
IndicatorShelter IslandNew YorkUSRank in New York*Table
Drive to work alone
48.1%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±37.4%
, number 513 ±439
48.8% ±0.1%
, number 4,538,595 ±14,030
68.8% ±0.1%
, number 109,447,738 ±95,800
778thA09005
Take public transit
20.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±15.3%
, number 213 ±181
22.4% ±0.1%
, number 2,080,498 ±12,130
3.5% ±<0.1%
, number 5,573,279 ±22,170
39thA09005
Work from home
25.1%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±16.7%
, number 268 ±202
14.9% ±0.1%
, number 1,389,935 ±12,520
15.1% ±<0.1%
, number 24,042,489 ±82,860
81stA09005
Commute 30 minutes or more
43.2% ±10.9%
, number 345 ±214
49.5% ±0.2%
, number 3,915,825 ±18,130
37.4% ±<0.1%
, number 50,453,122 ±73,600
336thB09001
Households with no vehicle
0.0%† (too uncertain to lean on) ±2.1%
, number 0 ±14
29.2% ±0.1%
, number 2,256,981 ±10,500
8.4% ±<0.1%
, number 10,793,323 ±27,220
811thA10030

*1 is the highest. Population is ranked among all places, and the rest among those of 1,000 people or more, whose figures can be ranked. Ranks use 5-year estimates, the only ones covering every community, so they can differ slightly from the figures here.

Places

In and around Shelter Island

Population, from the latest estimates available. Figures cover the whole of each place.

Places nearby

Its county

Places like this one

Places at least a third this size, with the closest income, education, age, housing and origins.

Turn Shelter Island into your planning report.

Social Explorer Studio builds an editable profile of any place, with tables and charts beside the county and state, and exports to Word, PDF and Excel.

Questions about Shelter Island

What is the population of Shelter Island, New York?

2,125 people (±647), according to the ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates. That’s the 607th largest of 1,289 places in New York.

What is the FIPS code for Shelter Island, New York?

3666828. The first two digits, 36, are New York’s state code, and the last five, 66828, identify Shelter Island within it. The Census Bureau’s full geographic identifier (GEOID) is 1600000US3666828.

What county is Shelter Island in?

Shelter Island is in Suffolk County.

What is the median household income in Shelter Island?

The ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates put it at $165,734 (±$120,200), a margin too wide to lean on.

What is the median age in Shelter Island?

41.3 years (±2.3), according to the ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates, about the same as New York (39.8) but higher than the US (38.9).

Where do people who work in Shelter Island live?

104 of its 548 jobs are held by people who live here. Of those who commute in, the most come from Shelter Island Heights CDP, Southold CDP, Greenport village.

Where does this census data come from?

The U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey, through Social Explorer’s tables: the latest 1-year estimates where they exist, for the most recent numbers, and 5-year estimates otherwise. Each table lists its code, so you can find it again.

Is this data free to use?

Yes. You can read it, cite it, download the CSV and embed the charts, with no account. To map other variables, compare your own areas or build a report, see Social Explorer’s plans in a live demo.

Sources and how to cite

American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, U.S. Census Bureau, from Social Explorer’s tables A00001, A00002, A01004, A04001, A06001, A08001, A09005, A10001, A10003, A10008, A10030, A10036, A10040, A10047, A10055, A10060, A12001, A13004, A14006, A14024, A14028, A16002, A17005, A18002, A18009, A20001, B02002, B09001, B13002, B18101, C16001. Maps by census tract use 2020–2024 5-year estimates, since the 1-year survey doesn’t cover tracts. Commuting: LEHD LODES 2023. These are estimates from a sample, each with its margin of error. Data retrieved November 14, 2026. How these profiles are made.

U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, via Social Explorer. “Shelter Island, New York.” https://www.socialexplorer.com/places/new-york/shelter-island-cdp. Accessed November 14, 2026.